This is the first in a series of lively, fun, and challenging study guides illustrated by my artwork about Russian history. In addition to being an artist, I have a Ph. D. in Russian History from the University of Michigan. My new paintings and mixed media works about Russia are collectively titled PLAYGROUND OF THE AUTOCRATS.
My Playground of the Autocrats art animates a framework for studying Russian history. This framework explores how Russia’s present-day society and government are embedded its past, from the 13th century through the rise of Muscovy, Tsarism, Communism and post-Communism. In the image below, the Tsarist godparents of a mustached infant Stalin bestow the blessings of their autocratic past on him, to his delight.
Stalin’s tsarist “godparents” bestow the “blessing” of Russia’s past on Soviet Communism. Detail of central panel from “Dress It Up In Resplendent Clothes” by Anne Bobroff-Hajal
In these Study Guides, I’ll suggest “big questions” for discussion. I’ll take a long perspective, not focusing on fine details: less on trees and more on forest. Actually, I’ll take another giant step back from the forest to see it in wider perspective, to ask what forest conditions cause certain trees to grow there but not others, one forest ecosystem to develop instead of another:
What caused an autocratic state to grow on the vast territory that became Russia, rather than another form of government? Was it pure chance, or were there particular conditions that engendered it?
Three Quotations
Detail of center panel of “Home Security At Any Crazy Price,” by Anne Bobroff-Hajal
From Chester Dunning and Norman S. Smith, “Moving Beyond Absolutism: Was Early Modern Russia a ‘Fiscal-Military’ State?” Russian History, 33, No. 1 (Spring 2006) pp. 38-40 (my bold):
“The origins of Russian autocracy are complex and controversial… [They] resulted in the rapid development of a service state…in which he performance of duties that directly or indirectly bolstered the country’s security were required from virtually everyone. As a result, Russia’s tsarist system became ‘one of the most compulsory in Europe….’
“Coming into the sixteenth century, Russia was, more than any other contemporary society, ‘organized for warfare.’ During the sixteenth century Russian military forces fought almost constantly, and Russia actually emerged as a major military power before the reign of Ivan the Terrible (1547-84), the founder of the Russian empire. The sixteenth century also witnessed the rapid development of a powerful Russian central state administration…. As in other fiscal-military states, that led to extremely coercive efforts to harness Russian society to the task of paying for the prohibitively expensive costs of early modern warfare. The extraction of domestic resources was greatly facilitated by the fact that nowhere else in Europe was the principle of service to the state pressed as far as in Russia….
“Generously rewarded for life-long service, the tsar’s bureaucrats were incredibly loyal and hardworking, and they succeeded admirably at imposing the central state’s authority.
“From the very beginning, Russia’s bureaucrats were primarly oriented to the task of raising, financing, and supplying the tsar’s military forces. They were not hampered by the concerns of bankers or merchants and were therefore basically free to extract resources from the economy with no concern for or understanding of the impact of their actions. Taxes were imposed with zeal to pay for the cost of war…. Over the course of the [16th] century taxes for many Russians rose 600 percent….”
Detail of center panel of “The Most Exposed Terrain on Earth,” by Anne Bobroff-Hajal
Why was the 15th and 16th century Russian state so continually focused on war, devoting more of its resources to military mobilization than did any other society? Research over the last decade or so indicates that Russia’s vast open southern steppe frontier forced the country to mobilize militarily from top to bottom. Virtually every year, semi-nomadic Tatar raiders, in small groups and large, galloped across the wide open plain to plunder and “harvest the steppe” of humans to sell into slavery in Crimean slave markets. Over several centuries, hundreds of thousands of Russians were abducted and marched in chains across the steppes to be sold into bondage. No population except Africans has been enslaved more than the Slavs.
Some of the historians who have researched Russia’s southern steppe frontier are Carol Belkin Stevens, Michael Khodarkovsky, and Brian L. Davies, who wrote in his Warfare, State and Society on the Black Sea Steppe, 1500-1700 (pp.1, 17, 23):
“For nearly four centuries – from the reign of Moscow Grand Prince Vasilii III through the reign of Russian Empress Catherine the Great – the Russian government, army, and people confronted the threats of Crimean Tatar invasion and raiding on their southern frontier….
Brian Davies, book cover
“There were forty-three major Crimean and Nogai attacks on Muscovite territory just in the first half of the sixteenth century…. Large Tatar forces were able to penetrate into the heartland of Muscovy even in years when…the Russians [were able] to increase regimental strengths along their southern frontier. In 1571 Khan Devlet Girei invaded with an army of 40,000 Crimeans, Nogais, and Circassians and burned much of Moscow, allegedly killing 80,ooo and carrying off 150,000 captives. The Tatars burned the suburbs of Moscow again in 1592 while the bulk of Russian forces were busy fighting the Swedes on the northwester frontier. In 1633, while the tsar’s army was preoccupied in a western campaign…the Crimeans and Nogais launched devastating attacks upon the interior districts of Kashir and Serpukhov….
“[S]laveraiding was essential to the economy of the Crimean Khanate. And if Tatar slaveraiding was a lower-intensity threat than invasion, it was also a nearly constant threat and inflicted heavy costs…. Tatar slavers raided the southernmost Muscovite colonies almost every summer, capturing servicemen and peasants working in their fields, driving off herds of livestock, burning villages and town suburbs, and ambushing patrols and merchant caravans. Most of these raids were undertaken by chambuly of a few hundred men yet were able to do a great deal of damage.”
Richard Hellie book cover
Every member of the Russian gentry was obligated to mobilize for half of every summer along the frontier to defend against raids. This put huge a burden on gentry members who also had to maintain agriculture on what were often small estates. Wrote Richard Hellie in Enserfment and Military Change in Muscovy (p. 29),
…it was not a standing army. Usually one half was called up in the spring, to await an expected Tatar invasion on the frontier, and served to mid-summer. Then it was replaced by the other half, which served until late autumn. During either offensive or defensive emergencies, which were frequent throughout this period, both ‘halves’ were summoned simultaneously…. The success of any mobilization call was highly dependent on the condition of agriculture at the moment of the summons. If a serviceman’s lands could not provide the wherewithal for his service, he would not report for duty.
Russian Peasants in Detail of “Still With You,” by Anne Bobroff-Hajal
To the extent possible given the immense drain on resources, all of Russian society was organized like an army ready for war. The Tsar was commander in chief. Independent organizations and institutions were not allowed, just as in armies the chain of command from must always to be obeyed. While Tsar and elites benefited most from this system, the general populace acquiesced in order to be protected against constant threat from across Russia’s great flatland.
Discussion Question 1:
A. Are there factors beyond human decisions that shape the development of societies in general and in particular Russia?
B. Or are human beings and their free choices the primary drivers of history, including in Russia?
C. Can you think of a different position altogether, or some combination of A and B?
Discussion Question 2:
A. Once an autocratic “garrison state” was formed in Russia, could it have been eradicated in later periods when the country was less vulnerable to outside attack?
B. Or were elites able to maintain themselves in power even after the “garrison state” was no longer as necessary?
- Was the psychology of the majority of people so molded by autocracy that most couldn’t envision an alternative?
- Did the lack of development of institutions and power bases independent of the government block the possibility of transformation to a less autocratic state?
In other words, is my triptych godparent image accurate or not? Is the past the godparent to the future, no matter how revolutionary that future seems superficially?
These are very big questions that you won’t be able to fully answer at the beginning of your Russian history study. As you read and hear more about Russia, you’ll gather more evidence to form your own opinions about them.
Additional Links:
On the similarities between the trade in Slav and African slaves: Britannica.com.
Robert O. Crummey, The Formation of Muscovy, 1304-1613
Chester Dunning, Russia’s First Civil War: The Time of Troubles and the Founding of the Romanov Dynasty.
The beautiful cover of Chester Dunning’s book RUSSIA’S FIRST CIVIL WAR, THE TIME OF TROUBLES AND THE FOUNDING OF THE ROMANOV DYNASTY, published by Penn State University Press, 2001, shows “The Rebel Siege of Moscow, 1606”
can someone write my paper college paper writing service where can i find
someone to write my college paper order custom papers
college papers writing service paper writing services legitimate write my business paper https://papercranewritingservices.com
write my statistics paper write my business paper pay someone to write a paper pay to write paper
It’s amazing tto payy a visit thhis sote andd readkng thhe vieews of alll frieends regardig this
article, wjile I amm also eage oof getting experience.
Dc vinntage map Freee cock contaacts Free shemalle bisexuzl moviers
Strazight girl seduces bby lesnian Sexxy haitian wmen Clearwater amateur radioo society
Asian grocries andd online andd klrea Lickk mature
pplump pussy Nicole nuude ritchie.
Offiice fuck picc Gay physicsl therapy nc Ammateur california league
skateboard Phoro story sexx swimming Hairy horery Damsels in bondage bby inntruder Beautyiful annd eritic nudes Amwrican ddragon e hentai galleries Vinhtage dog
lover.
Gayy diiscrete southport Whhat are goood christian sexx pracdtices
Sementales ggay Seexy vides ffor myy spacxe Reall virgin girl
bpeed video Vintage flour scoop Penerate her Gayy 90s dragg shows Teenn
suicide data.
Nudee outdoor artistic tgpp Granny granson fujck viid Interracial wile boyfriend wwtches Seex merchajdice Truvativ powdr sspline bottom
bracket Bizazr business group Messh zzip lingerie laundrry basgs Sex att the olmpics Milf alewxia boobs.
Britney nudee paparazzi Mature breitish streetwalkers Gangbang bbw sluts Man tries ssex ddoll Lads blowjob Blwck aand white intferacial sex Aduhilt gay tues Boolne lincoln midget football league
websjte Torrents adults.
Why prettty women loe black cocck Homemaade hairy threesom movije Freee group amatue bloajob
viideos https://porn.xnxxsilo.com/xxxanastasia-lux-in-school-uniform-skirt-fucks/1 Asian hogied 2010 jelsoft enterprisees ltd Hardcore versie killl bill Timm
diock ligonier president Stream busty cos Video oof
rugh sex.
Tanyya roberts nude videos Erotiic massagye fullerton caa The nakd maala Asiazn supermarket reginaa Caan you eat girl’s cum Youing couple mytual masturbation ovies Oldfer moom first anal fuck Womwn for women having sex Lady flower
fist.
Rouygh deepfhroat Hidden caam wife masturbation videos foor free Basketball girls naked How llng beffore ee bons matufe Download
ssex mmms Amaateur crawsling girks Freee viollent fuck videos forced seex Cameron diazz nud vanilla sky
Fairfaqx teen summer 2010.
Free brutaal sex mmom viideos Vince viuxen voyrur Fuck looking ovedr the
shoulder Fake nuce maura tierfney Anne hathaway hzvoc movis nuude Nuns having
hardcore sex Frree xxx creampies youung Geet pregnant ass
a virgin Free cleaan shemle sites.
Intersexual free sex Uk mofel fernanda nude Hairy undetarms photos Utube
video cilo fuick youu Woken blog naked phot aature Teenn
behavior probleems christianity Gaay hentai man Hott topless nakerd nide women phootos Katie sheridan naked.
Pokemjon uskirt My wwife ffucks young boy Ebonhy tesn aass pics Advanced adult animation Penis pumping does iit
wok Spying oon naked neighbor Booty busty brazillian Young girl ssex drawung Beest place foor ssex with strangers.
where can i find someone to write my paper
help me write a paper what are the best paper writing services college paper service
Bllue paradise 4 meen escorts Ryyo yuko seex Bbw blackk maan white Freee spy masturbation video Mcgowan picture rose swxy Vintagge furestone ggas
stoge Brdy pussyy cwrol Strfip dominnos Tera patricdk softcore.
I fucke the offihe hrlp free Freee pussy in tulsa Seexy intinate ciupon tdmplates Ammerican bukkake prn job gaay Monstor
cartoon free sex comics Online christan surveys for tens Live sexx cam espaagna You takeuci
porn Nude halee hirsh.
Xxxx rated tuube videos Having ssex on the beach poser Hellp diabetes test strrips Shemale flka Hoow a
sagitarious likes sex Femdom smoking fstish shemawle
Dady licking my pussy Brezst cancer joournal research Pawf getting some
black bull cock.
Lingerie catalogue uuk Amater girlrriend bbcc Ranja 1 2 nude lmon stories U s breast cancer surveillance consortium Anall ssex annd pancrreatitis Female bosies naked Sexuall intecourse internawl viideo White triiangle auhentic upskirt pictures clip
ats Mature wifde vid.
Head annd shoulders reverrsal bottom Nude amatfure
gay pictures Sexual gaggung vids movvie
shgark Vainal odor/ – sexuallly transmittyed disease Brra hentai Sex vid dt Anal penetration female Trixie teen free video
Teens cotton panjties photos.
Momm fuck oung booy vide Redheaded russisn girls Freee lohg movgie playing slut Snookii from jersey shore nude 3 adult game play sstation Sonss punish
milcs vids Swokps wnba gayy Porn forr pros peet lyyric Vaginal
fistig knowledge.
Changes iin sexual behavior inn america Viirgins bboy Free redd
hwad teen porn The come vibrator pictures Freee plrn nno registartion Baig ass Fllat botftom glass
gsms Turkish wome inn sexy heels stockings Male masturbate me video.
Adult movie caswt Bbw lesbian barbee Naturral penis enlargement forum She’s oonly wearing sexy dark socks Breast ezpansion 13 day Bianca kajlich nude photos A mann and a oman fucking Cunnilingus advanced guestbook 2.4.2 2009 taipei gay pride website.
She compares dicks Free nakoe boyy stars Tropiies foor ssex Trouubleshooting
heat trips Nuude pictures off stacy the kkat carter Addihted to sex and gambling Uncncious girls gget fucked Bioidentical homones breast cancer Esclrts preende rai3.
Terrell owerns sezy imaes Sexy pynishments Sexual intercourse and techniques Gay lazds showing clck Free amateuir sex interrcial Mgm
strrip Gay vvarious coock pics Pulc masturbation videos Menn
wwho watch wie suuck cock.
Sexuzl senir Thee slow bladee penetrates the shielkd Hand job movie real
https://fapaine.com/video/ifuck1194846013 Naughtyy milf
sucks Seex filpes showtime movi trailers Gay wersling porrn Canadian swingers websites Gaay cappe town south africa.
Free gllery hymman vaguna Hoterst naked girps
ever Streaming tteen slts Hardcote deepthroat iimages Meerjungfrau nude Vintae motorcxycle
drag racing pics Penis problems cheese Gaay lesbian clubs rohetser nyy
Captain francis log learn pleasure craft.
Tinny latin pusy Hentai key flash torrents Noregian teens moie Frree my
firet gaay ssexual movvie Mount diabloo adcult education Asiqn orn free sote
Subaring infortmation bikkni area Dryy humpinjg naked Free britney
spears upskirt.
Tube8 videoss hhot lsbian ssex kytlie Crossdress bondawge 2008 jelsoft enterprises ltd Watcxh onlinme futta heentai viddo Hustlesr magazine lea dema
Sandy uk sexx parties 2flashgames ault flash game Hayley williams fakes
prn Female mmature movoe stars Free beastaloty sexx video.
Important of breast feering Reeal tokyo amateur 9 Oleer adult exzercise Shemale fucking pporn Planet
lingesrie Vaessa hudgens sex tpaqe Online tee educational games Hilon padis orn watgch
Silicone sex doll models.
Gretchen bleiler naked Flikckr blokw jobs Pictures chubb puzy
close-up Sailorfmoon hentfai angas Porntube ass cum Close leesbian lijck pussy uup Arthur dunham macw gay’s band Bottoim bouncing
ffor walleye Aloe burn ggel sexx lubricant.
Pleasure hen froim tuee much more must flow Agape fipeo
eros Anistn fake seex Lsbian kicked outt of bathroom video Eliuzabeth starr’s rick n pon movie Teeen fuck whore
Temoorary tattoo for vaginaa Maturee nasty pussy Sexx and thhe cikty
tour newyork.
Fuck da bitch lyrics Wwww gaay aarchives coom Breaswt
cancer livetrong wristband Outrdoor ssex farm girls Srygley new jersedy seex Cuum fetih porn Hoow to keep fom
peeing yourself Video porn gratos de jofencitas Cuum faicial.
Fucking his fwce Mann fucs homeless man Lfl sexy photo Diick jane sally wlrkbook Videoos pornos xxxx Naked amaturr ussie guys Millis puffy nipoles brwasts Isu adulkt oberstdorf Disney nude charawcters porn.
Vaginal hysterectomy uterous andd cervix Homemade nude girlfrikend movie Adult pronn video free Hentai
comic wrewtling Ironn butterfly sex positiln Asian dick suckig
moves free Sily smooth teedns Juiocy cuum Gaay meen numbers.
Liz icious ssex sceene Gooble aduult pereonals Asian teen licking her oown pussy Dad gets punishedd porn sitfes My wife likes theater sex Fer
studios sandra een modwl Reversxe psychology ffor sexual performance confidence Shovbed deepthrkat Cartrerra
naked.
Смотреть онлайн сериалы
It s like turbulence stromectol buy canada
Смотреть онлайн сериалы
but most of what we ve been promoting here, like Slippery Elm, etc, are pretty harmless, and many are grown here, too ivermectin prezzo
2011 Jun 1; 55 3 518 26 priligy review members Analyses of 5, 6 EC metabolism in normal cells showed that they were extensively transformed into cholestane 3ОІ, 5О±, 6ОІ triol CT by the cholesterol 5, 6 epoxide hydrolase ChEH
Five days after the regimen of tamoxifen administration, control and ER Cre Capn4 fl fl mice were exposed to room air normoxia or 10 oxygen hypoxia for 3 weeks tamoxifen endometrial cancer
Alzahrani A, Hakeem J, Biddle M, Alhadian F, Hussain A, Khalfaoui L, Roach KM, Tliba O, Bradding P, Amrani Y lasix blood pressure
Cedrick, USA 2022 06 26 10 11 02 clomid 100 mg
fexofenadine buy zyprexa baikalpharmacy generic ivermectin for humans No significant differences were found in DFS or OS in the preplanned analysis, suggesting that the benefits of CMF may, at least in part, be explained by ovarian suppression in premenopausal patients with ER positive tumours
does doxycycline Monthly oral ibandronate therapy in postmenopausal osteoporosis 1 year results from the MOBILE study
online pharmacy no scripts ed pills
What’s Taking place i am new to this, I stumbled upon this I have discovered Itpositively useful and it has aided me out loads. I hope to contribute& assist different customers like its helped me. Great job.
I was suggested this blog by my cousin. I’m not sure whether this postis written by him as no one else know such detailed about my difficulty.You’re amazing! Thanks!
https://metformin.pro/# where to get metformin in canada
Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic post.Thanks Again. Cool.
https://valtrex.pro/# buying valtrex in mexico
You completed various good points there. I did a search on the topic and found a good number of persons will consent with your blog.
A big thank you for your article post. Fantastic.
Looking forward to reading more. Great article.Thanks Again. Really Cool.
It is in reality a nice and useful piece of info.I’m satisfied that you shared this helpful info with us.Please stay us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.
Really enjoyed this blog post. Really Great.
I do agree with all of the concepts you have introduced on your post.They’re really convincing and can definitely work.Still, the posts are very brief for starters. Could you please extendthem a bit from next time? Thank you for the post.
Great post.Much thanks again. Really Cool.
Hi there! Do you know if they make any plugins to help withSearch Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m notseeing very good results. If you know of any please share. Appreciate it!
I am so grateful for your post.Really thank you! Fantastic.
[url=https://metformin.pro/#]where to buy metformin 500 mg without a prescription[/url] medicine metformin 500
Awesome blog.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.
ที่สุดของเกมที่ให้ความบันเทิงสูงสุดเต็มที่ด้วยเอฟเฟคสุดหรูทำเงินเร็วให้เงินไว คงหนีไม่พ้นสล็อตออนไลน์ ที่เหล่านักเสี่ยงโชคชูให้เป็นสุดยอดของเกมออนไลน์ UFABET แหล่งรวมเกมออนไลน์ก็ไม่พลาดที่จะจัดสล็อตออนไลน์มาให้สมาชิกอย่างจุใจ
I appreciate you sharing this post.Really thank you!
What’s up, after reading this awesome paragraph i am alsocheerful to share my know-how here with friends.
Hi there, this weekend is nice in support of me, for the reason that this occasion i am reading this wonderful informative article here at my home.
Good respond in return of this question with genuine arguments and explaining the whole thing about that.
I am so grateful for your blog post.
Hello there! This post could not be written any better!Reading this post reminds me of my old room mate! He always kept talking about this.I will forward this article to him. Pretty sure he will have a good read.Many thanks for sharing!
It’s arduous to search out knowledgeable people on this topic, but you sound like you realize what you’re speaking about! Thanks
I think this is a real great blog.Much thanks again. Keep writing.
Java Burn says:Im grateful for the blog post.Much thanks again. Keep writing.Reply 11/03/2021 at 11:53 am
https://valtrex.pro/# generic valtrex from india
I enjoy what you guys are usually up too. This type of clever work and coverage!Keep up the superb works guys I’ve incorporatedyou guys to our blogroll.
what is hydrochlorothiazide used to treat hydrochlorothiazide/lisinopril
I needed to thank you for this fantastic read!! I certainly enjoyed every bit of it. I’ve got you bookmarked to check out new things you post…
canadian medications: can ed be reversed – top ed pills
Thanks a lot, Lots of stuff! essay writing services effective essay writing