Fine art from photos, OK. But fine art from snapshots?

June 2nd, 2008

(Already read Part 1? Here’s Part 2)

So you’re going to have your portrait painted. That means you’ll sit in a studio for hours on end while the artist paints you, right?

Well, it used to mean that. But click “Procedure” on almost any portrait artist’s website – including those who get $10,000 and up for a portrait. You’ll find that these days the “portrait sitting” is commonly a photo shoot that happens before the artist’s brush ever strokes canvas. After the shoot, the client and the artist select a photograph on which to base the portrait. Then the client can disappear while the lengthy work of the actual painting is accomplished.

“Assuming that a portrait created from photo reference is intrinsically inferior to one painted from life is putting the responsibility on the process rather than the artist. If only it were that simple. You can paint from life until the next millennium and never do anything worthwhile.

I’ve seen incredible paintings done from life and beautiful paintings done from photos too. However, the vast majority of portraits I’ve seen are poorly thought out and ineptly handled regardless of whether from life or photo reference.

I believe that injecting the quality of life into a painting comes from the artist’s heart, intent, knowledge and talent.”

Marvin Mattelson, Portrait artist, permanent collection of the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the National Portrait Gallery. (http://forum.portraitartist.com/showthread.php?t=8582)

There are still a few portrait artists – such as Mary Minifie in Boston – who insist on the importance of working only from life. Some other portraitists accompany their photo sessions with quick, one-time studies (sketches) from life. Afterwards, they paint the portrait itself without the subject present.

Portrait by Jonathan Linton, full size at: http://www.jonathanlinton.com/painting-pages/chad_big.htmlWhen the painter is a terrific artist to begin with, painting from photographs can create exquisite portraits, the kind of art you want to gaze at forever. Look at this beautiful little boy (Full size portrait by Jonathan Linton here).  His eyes speak to you, appealing to you emotionally. Every detail of the background creates a very unusual atmosphere. The boy, chair, hangings, and window all hint at a mysterious story that engages us and makes us wish we could know more.

There are many good reasons why portraitists have shifted to using photos. Clients don’t want to take time or energy to travel repeatedly to the artist’s studio and sit motionless for the endless hours it takes to paint a portrait. A subject who poses usually gets tired and bored as time passes. The head droops, shadows shift, angles change, new wrinkles appear in clothing. All make painting problematic. So artists have always seized on technological tools as fast as they’re invented, to develop new ways of capturing their subjects in paint.

Of course, portraitists who successfully use photographs are able to do so because they have trained endlessly in drawing from life. They have a vast bank of experience observing and painting the myriad elements of color, line, human physique, and so on. When portrait artists paint from photographs, they are drawing on this store of knowledge and practice.

Copying a photo will not make a great painting, but neither will copying from life. It is the understanding that the artist brings to his work that makes it something more. How to strategize the construction of a painting is the commonality I believe that distinguishes the work of all great artists.

I think that if the old masters were alive today they would absolutely take full advantage of today’s technology and couple it with their extraordinary knowledge. Great artists are always looking to utilize whatever will make themselves more effective. Vermeer used optical devices. Bouguereau and Gerome both took full advantage of photography, and look how they raised the bar.

Marvin Mattelson

But how can art grow from snapshots?

Many in the art world insist that portraitists who paint from photographs use only photos the artist takes him or herself. Many portrait competitions stipulate this. The reason is to prove that the artist isn’t using some one else’s vision, some one else’s composition, lighting, color choices, and so on. Rather, the artist must make all these choices, based on their own artistry and technical skill.

It’s easy to understand the perspective that a painting based on a photo taken by some one else – or worse, some magazine photo of a well-known person – isn’t art. Online portrait factories (“send me your family snapshot and I’ll turn it into a portrait and mail it back to you”) have proliferated. You can have a $100 copy painted of your own photo without even meeting the painter. I would not argue that such an approach produces great art.

At the same time, I’d like to bring another perspective to personal snapshots. I believe that, treated properly, they can indeed be central to a work of art. I’ll write more about this out-of-the-box approach next post.

(All done with Part 1? Here’s Part 2)

95,053 Responses to “Fine art from photos, OK. But fine art from snapshots?”

  1. I enjoyed reading your blog, Anne – very well written and thought-out.

    And, of course you are welcome to include the portraits that you mentioned in your email.

    Cheers,

    Ned Bittinger

  2. Dear Anne

    I was delighted to hear from you and very happy that you have chosen to use my painting on your blog. I agree that placement is a fascinating consideration and have noticed that empty central space with pictorial elements occuring on the perifiry seems a particularly tricky balance for people to adjust to. We have such strong conditioning to read the content of an image, I would hazard the option that this comes before viewing visual dynamics yet composition is central to the timbre of a portrait. By the way, I shall send you a higher resolution image and hope that we correspond more.

    Kind regards
    Marilyn Bailey

  3. Ann Ladd Ferencz says:

    Anne I love your blog, When do you sleep?
    The 24″x36″ portraits look fine and normal.
    It’s wonderful to see the wide variety of styles and positions and things to sit on in all the samples you display.
    People are so much fun to look at when captured forever in one moment.
    Makes me want to start painting portraits!, Ann

  4. ShawnAlaric says:

    thank you so much for this amazing site me and my phratr admired this satisfied and brainstorm

  5. LuccaZion says:

    😀 thank you so much for this awe-inspiring website me and my sept favored this contentedness and brainstorm

  6. 😃 thank you so much for this awesome web site me and my sept precious this satisfied and penetration

  7. 😃 thank you so much for this awe-inspiring site me and my family precious this depicted object and penetration

  8. JaimeZev says:

    😃 thank you so much for this astonishing website me and my phratr precious this satisfied and perceptiveness

  9. BrettMiguel says:

    😀 thank you so much for this astonishing web site me and my kin admired this content and brainstorm

  10. Josezalire says:

    super cialis
    cialis viagra levitra comparison
    cialis over the counter walmart
    – can i take cialis with propranolol
    [url=https://walmartcialis.net]cialis at walmart
    [/url] cialis 20mg canada faq

  11. Stezesof says:

    cialis 5mg canada announcements
    cialis no prescription
    cialis after prostate surgery
    – which is more efective viagra, cialis oot levitra,
    [url=https://walmart-tadalafil.net]cialis manufacturer coupon lilly
    [/url] cialis online overnight hot thread with no new posts

  12. RichardOrarF says:

    [url=http://neurontintab.online/]buy gabapentin online no prescription[/url] [url=http://buyprednisone.works/]3000mg prednisone[/url]

  13. MarkSoirm says:

    [url=https://celebrex.guru/]celebrex nz[/url]

  14. RodneyWen says:

    [url=http://levaquin.shop/]levaquin tablets[/url]

  15. Best good quality USA proxies – https://DreamProxies.com sequence together with 50 price cut!

  16. BooSoirm says:

    [url=https://avodart.email/]generic for avodart[/url]

  17. TedSoirm says:

    [url=https://celebrex.guru/]celebrex brand cost[/url]

  18. Michaeltrase says:

    [url=http://propranololtabs.online/]inderal medicine[/url]

  19. NickSoirm says:

    [url=http://buyatarax.works/]buy atarax online usa[/url]

  20. Edgarbetty says:

    [url=http://modafiniltab.online/]can i buy provigil in mexico[/url]

  21. NickSoirm says:

    [url=http://fluoxetine.boutique/]prozac 10 mg[/url]

  22. MarySoirm says:

    [url=https://buystromectol.works/]ivermectin brand[/url] [url=https://buyventolin.monster/]albuterol over the counter[/url] [url=https://prednisolone.guru/]prednisolone 3 mg[/url] [url=https://valtrex.works/]purchase generic valtrex online[/url]

  23. I love your blog.. very nice colors & theme. Did you make this website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you? Plz respond as I’m looking to construct my own blog and would like to find out where u got this from. appreciate it

  24. Edgarbetty says:

    [url=http://baclofen.fun/]baclofen purchase[/url]

  25. DavidRix says:

    [url=https://anafranil.xyz/]anafranil cost[/url]

  26. KimSoirm says:

    [url=https://zoloft.fun/]zoloft[/url]

  27. Hello There. I discovered your blog the usage of msn. This is a really smartly written article. I’ll be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful information. Thank you for the post. I’ll definitely comeback.

  28. SueSoirm says:

    [url=http://viagradtabs.quest/]sildenafil 25 mg price in india[/url]

  29. DenSoirm says:

    [url=http://kamagra.live/]kamagra jelly 100mg amazon[/url]

  30. SueSoirm says:

    [url=http://effexor.fun/]effexor generic cost[/url]

  31. UgoSoirm says:

    [url=http://buycipro.quest/]ciprofloxacin over the counter canada[/url]

  32. SueSoirm says:

    [url=http://bactrim.sbs/]bactrim 250 mg[/url]

  33. BooSoirm says:

    [url=https://benicar.works/]benicar 50 mg[/url]

  34. KimSoirm says:

    [url=https://glucophage.fun/]metformin 150 mg[/url]

  35. TimothyGob says:

    [url=http://dexamethasone.cfd/]dexamethasone canadian pharmacy[/url]

  36. MichaelProox says:

    [url=https://cialiswtab.quest/]cialis 5 coupon[/url]

  37. Jasonced says:

    incognito market url how to order from dark web [url=https://darknetmarketprivate.shop/ ]reddit darknet market superlist [/url]

  38. Williamjax says:

    dark markets luxembourg darknet market oz [url=https://darknetdarkwebmarkets.com/ ]darknet black market [/url]

  39. Damonspilk says:

    dark markets bulgaria dark web drugs nz [url=https://darknetdrugmarketplace.com/ ]list of darknet drug markets [/url]

  40. RalphToism says:

    tor best websites darknet markets address [url=https://darknet-webmart.shop/ ]how to find the black market online [/url]

  41. Corryeasek says:

    tor marketplace darknet dream market link [url=https://darknet-tor-markets.com/ ]darknet market news [/url]

  42. DanielAwato says:

    best working darknet market 2022 dark markets argentina [url=https://darknetdmarketsweb.com/ ]darknet markets noob [/url]

  43. Jamestaf says:

    archetyp market url best dark web markets [url=https://darknetactivemarkets.link/ ]darknet markets still open [/url]

  44. TornNex says:

    australian darknet markets pill with crown on it [url=https://darknet-tor-market.shop/ ]dark markets australia [/url]

  45. Shaneimmex says:

    current darknet market list cheap darknet websites dor drugs [url=https://darknetdruglist24.link/ ]darknet market noobs bible [/url]

  46. Robertdix says:

    black market website names urls for darknet markets [url=https://darknetdrugstoree.shop/ ]the dark web url [/url]